Much excitement! Halloween week last year was one of my favourite Strictly weeks ever! It's great to have a theme. Glad they're not doing a theme every week as I do like to see a classic dance performance too but it's great to have them thrown in there. Well done producers!
Anyway, onto the show. I annoyingly had to wait til about midnight to watch the show when it appeared on Iplayer and then managed to watch most of it last night before watching the remainder this morning.
Glad to see everyone taking part in the 'Adams Family' opening though it would have been amazing to have a Pro dance.. perhaps that'll come in the Results show tonight (*hoping*)
Onto the couples...
Russell & Flavia 6 Samba
The samba was not a dance of fear for Russell as it is for most of the celebrities. He had a great bounce action, was demonstrating actual samba steps and it was just a big shame that he went wrong a few times. It was a hard dance to do in Halloween week and I wondered how it could still be a 'party' dance but it was. I throughly enjoyed the performance to 'Better the Devil You Know'. Well done and fingers crossed for next week.
Chelsee & Pasha 8 Tango
I was with Bruce... I didn't notice the dress malfunction. I had to rewatch the dance to see what the fuss was about. I noticed that she started to look less comfortable towards the end but wasn't sure why. So we'll not talk about that anymore. the dance was strong and powerful. It was a bit over the top, dramatically, but I suppose it is Halloween week so they were going for the performance aspect. I think that the tango loses the tension when you start to really play it so forceful and strong but that's me being nitty-picky. I would have prefered more subtleness.
Audley & Natalie 6 Jive
This guy does have swing and style up top. I really enjoyed the performance. It did look like he was struggling to move his feet fast enough for the steps but he did a passable job and I hope he is voted through to next week when he has more time to train. It woudl be interesting to see how much better he could actually get.
Alex & James 7 Paso Doble
I loved the costumes. Alex looked like Christine from 'Phantom of the Opera' and James made a good Dracula. It was a good performance. I liked James' idea of Alex using her skirt almost like a cape at the start of the routine though it did go on slightly too long for my liking but Alex may have needed that long to get into the role and get settled into performing alone. There were some good actual Paso steps in the routine. Alex still looked somewhat flimsy in some of her actions and nervy but she was really trying to hide that with a more confident performance. I still believe she has lots of potential.
Holly & Artem 9 American Smooth (Black Swan)
Stunning costumes. This was a beautiful show piece. I wish it had been more Ballroom dancing as the opening section was really good but then it just went into a show routine which was fabulous. A great achievement and I won't continue to moan about the lack of content as it was a great routine. (However it may have been closer to a 10 if I'd seen more good ballroom)
Nancy & Anton 3 Rumba
I think this dance should have been Nancy's best hope but it failed unfortunately. The dance steps looked plonky and she looked unfeminine throughout.
Harry & Aliona 9 Tango
This man is good! I was swaying between an 8 and a 9 but his small tango section has pushed it up to a 9. He had the flexed knees, his posture was fantastic and his performance was brilliant.
Robbie & Ola 8 Paso Doble
Loved the Michael Jackson element in this routine. Robbie has so much oomph and potential. He looks so eager to learn and Ola must be working so hard with him. His walks weren't perfect style for Paso.. I think he needs to pull his posture up some more but I did enjoy it.
Anita & Robin 7 Tango
You can't say this performance wasn't dramatic but I didn't really enjoy it. Anita did do well and achieved a routine with lots of tango elements but I was distracted by the 'devilish' facial expressions.
Lulu & Brendan 7 Paso Doble
I loved their performance. Great idea Brendan! Lulu did it with such determination and great performance. I want to give them more points but I do think her feet aren't as good. I hope the technique improves each week as her confidence is growing each week.
Jason & Kristina 9 Quickstep
Excellent routine. They both gave us a great finale to the show. I did suspect Jason had gone wrong slightly but it didn't distract from the routine. I'd also like his elbows to be lifted to improve his posture some more. His steps were fluent. It was a light, 'bewitching' quickstep. Loved it. Definitely the couple to watch!
Top Couple tonight:- Jason & Kristina's Quickstep
Routine I want to watch again (and have!) - Lulu & Brendan
Couple to leave - Nancy & Anton
Best Costumes: - Alex & James (very classic Halloween and fitting to the dance) and Holly & Artem (stunning)
Cutest VT - Audley's daughter being twirled by Audley.
Sunday, 30 October 2011
Sunday, 23 October 2011
I'd miss it like a limb
Floods of tears... I mean... FLOODS of tears....
Is there something wrong with me? I knew he was in danger.. I didn't vote for him. When someone has been affected that much by dancing it makes me so sad. Not even sad... devasted. I'm still in floods of tears while writing this. I knew he was leaving (spoilers in the forums) but knowing didn't make it any easier. I didn't realise how sad he'd be. How sad Erin would be. How sad I am knowing now that he loved dancing so much. The moment Rory said "I'd miss it like a limb" to Claudia [when she asked him what he'd do if he wasn't going to be there next week] was the moment I started crying.
This love for Ballroom is something I share. It's actually pretty hard to describe just WHY it is such a wonderful form of dance. I dance just about every type of dance and if I had to pick one and only one to be able to do, it would be Ballroom. (Still in floods of tears
Is there something wrong with me? I knew he was in danger.. I didn't vote for him. When someone has been affected that much by dancing it makes me so sad. Not even sad... devasted. I'm still in floods of tears while writing this. I knew he was leaving (spoilers in the forums) but knowing didn't make it any easier. I didn't realise how sad he'd be. How sad Erin would be. How sad I am knowing now that he loved dancing so much. The moment Rory said "I'd miss it like a limb" to Claudia [when she asked him what he'd do if he wasn't going to be there next week] was the moment I started crying.
This love for Ballroom is something I share. It's actually pretty hard to describe just WHY it is such a wonderful form of dance. I dance just about every type of dance and if I had to pick one and only one to be able to do, it would be Ballroom. (Still in floods of tears
Saturday, 22 October 2011
Week 4 Scores
Rory & Erin 6 (Cha Cha)
Great attempt and he can obviously use his hips but the grinding and rotating made me grimace rather than be turned on. Much preferred him doing Ballroom.
Nancy & Anton 4 (Paso Doble)
Walking... walking... and more walking. Really not keen on Nancy's attempt at dance.
Lulu & Brendan 6 (Samba)
Absolutely loved the red costumes. Loved the energy and performance. Lulu's samba technique needed work but showed lots of promise. I also liked the 'using of the stairs' up to the other pro's and celebrities.. it may have taken time out of the actual dance routine.. but it felt like they got support when they went up those stairs and then they came back down with warmth and love from their fellow competitors.(may be just me being a bit soppy!)
Chelsee & Pasha 8 (Quickstep - Sing Sing Sing)
Bright, bubbly. I liked the airhostess theme. Lots of energetic steps. At times I would have prefered there to be more body contact but with all the jumps and charlston steps they were doing it was probably hard to maintain that.
Harry & Aliona 9 (Waltz)
The waltz was absolutely beautiful. I didn't want it to stop and then they came out of hold. I wanted more waltz. I did like the story telling but the waltz was so good I wanted more. I felt like I was cheated out of more exquisite waltz.
Sidenote: I'm sorry Tess... I'm not a fan of your swirly purple dress.
Anita & Robin 5 (American Smooth)
Very clever camera effect with the black and white picture.
I did feel however that Anita looked nervous and was almost running and wobbly throughout the routine. Her smile is gorgeous so she's obviously used to performing but I thought the actual dancing wasn't really there tonight. There were several mistakes and it just seemed like she wasn't confident with what she was doing.
Robbie & Ola 7 (Jive)
So light on his feet during all the flicks and kicks. Fabulous performance! Really got into the 'love man' role! Basic jive work was a great attempt. There wasn't any hip swing in the basic steps but it was made up for in the lightness of feet and fabulous performance! (Did part of Ola's dress come flying off - beads perhaps - when Robbie swung her skirt?)
Russell & Flavia 6 (Tango)
Good to see the actual tango steps in the routine. I felt it was a bit too 'fantasy'.. I would have preferred more actual 'tango' performance during the middle section of the routine (stacatto/knees flexed/atmosphere) but I really enjoyed watching it as a show piece.
I'm waiting for Iplayer to watch the following dances as I got in from work after these guys had performed. (I did see Audley & Natalie but wasn't watching them as I was attending to my cats. They didn't understand that 'Strictly' was on and just wanted food!). I'll edit my post when I've watched them. (I've now edited the post and added my reviews below)
Jason & Kristina 7 (Paso Doble)
I liked their costumes. They certainly looked the part of the Paso Doble. I'm not sure what I didn't really like about it.. but it seemed a bit like a series of steps rather than a complete dance. Almost like Jason was counting in his head. There were moments where steps looked a bit skippy too. It could have been the music - much as I like Queen the music seemed a bit repetitive which could have made the steps seem like they were danced repetitvely. I can't quite put my finger on it. Jason is certainly very talented and performed with conviction and aggression - this just wasn't a performance that thrilled me. I'm sorry.
Alex & James 5 (Rumba)
Well if anyone could look gorgeous in a sheer catsuit it is Alex. She looked stunning but in my opinion also looked quite self-concious. She hit all her lines but I was just willing for her to really push down into the floor and use her hips. The costume was very brave but I think perhaps something with a little bit more material may have given her the confidence to use those hips. She also seemed to be struggling to move in the high heels. It was like she was dancing on top of the floor instead of using the floor to aid her. It is a tough dance and she did look good but it was more a case of 'picture' moments rather than dancing. If it hadn't been a rumba, I would have marked higher. I loved the 'Bolero' beginning.
Audley & Natalie 5 (Foxtrot)
What a beautiful dress Natalie wore! This looked lovely.. but Audley's dancing of the foxtrot was only a 5 to me. I did enjoy the performance and he looked very comfortable but I wanted him to step out some more and really feel the dance through his feet and legs. His posture was very good and his smile was adorable.
Looking forward to next week's Halloween special! Last year's one was so good so I hope this one lives up to expectations! I do like the idea of themes. I think it keeps Strictly fresh though I do hope they don't go away from the actual dances too much.
Couples who I think are in danger this week:-
Audley & Natalie, Rory & Erin, Nancy & Anton.
Couple who I think should leave: still Nancy & Anton
Couple who surprised me the most this week: Chelsee and Pasha - didn't think she coudl produce a quickstep like that. Was really surprised and thrilled.
My opinon on the rift between the judges and professional dancers that seems to be arising:- It's a tricky one. I can see why the professionals are frustrated by the seemingly constant references to their choreography (and I know I do it as well) but it does contribute to the celebrity's performance. Their ability to choreograph for their particular celebrity really does come into play. I suppose it's a bit like song choice on 'singing' shows. The choice of song REALLY does make a difference as does the choice of choreography on Strictly. I understand why it is hard for the judges not to comment on the choreography when it makes such a difference to the performance and I also understand why the professionals are upset that their choreography is being criticised when it seems that the focus should be on the 'dancing' ability of the celebrity. I don't think there's anything wrong with talking about the choreography but perhaps the judges could focus more on the celebritiy's dance ability before taking the choreography into account.. perhaps more a 70/30% situation? I think the pro's objections are more to when 'just' the choreography is being discussed and not the performance of the celebrity or when the choreography is deemed to be the downside to a performance. Professional dancers/teachers follow a code of professional etiquette whereby we don't criticise other professional's work and support our fellow professionals. I think perhaps some of the pros on Strictly feel that this practise is not being followed. It's a tricky situation.
Great attempt and he can obviously use his hips but the grinding and rotating made me grimace rather than be turned on. Much preferred him doing Ballroom.
Nancy & Anton 4 (Paso Doble)
Walking... walking... and more walking. Really not keen on Nancy's attempt at dance.
Lulu & Brendan 6 (Samba)
Absolutely loved the red costumes. Loved the energy and performance. Lulu's samba technique needed work but showed lots of promise. I also liked the 'using of the stairs' up to the other pro's and celebrities.. it may have taken time out of the actual dance routine.. but it felt like they got support when they went up those stairs and then they came back down with warmth and love from their fellow competitors.(may be just me being a bit soppy!)
Chelsee & Pasha 8 (Quickstep - Sing Sing Sing)
Bright, bubbly. I liked the airhostess theme. Lots of energetic steps. At times I would have prefered there to be more body contact but with all the jumps and charlston steps they were doing it was probably hard to maintain that.
Harry & Aliona 9 (Waltz)
The waltz was absolutely beautiful. I didn't want it to stop and then they came out of hold. I wanted more waltz. I did like the story telling but the waltz was so good I wanted more. I felt like I was cheated out of more exquisite waltz.
Sidenote: I'm sorry Tess... I'm not a fan of your swirly purple dress.
Anita & Robin 5 (American Smooth)
Very clever camera effect with the black and white picture.
I did feel however that Anita looked nervous and was almost running and wobbly throughout the routine. Her smile is gorgeous so she's obviously used to performing but I thought the actual dancing wasn't really there tonight. There were several mistakes and it just seemed like she wasn't confident with what she was doing.
Robbie & Ola 7 (Jive)
So light on his feet during all the flicks and kicks. Fabulous performance! Really got into the 'love man' role! Basic jive work was a great attempt. There wasn't any hip swing in the basic steps but it was made up for in the lightness of feet and fabulous performance! (Did part of Ola's dress come flying off - beads perhaps - when Robbie swung her skirt?)
Russell & Flavia 6 (Tango)
Good to see the actual tango steps in the routine. I felt it was a bit too 'fantasy'.. I would have preferred more actual 'tango' performance during the middle section of the routine (stacatto/knees flexed/atmosphere) but I really enjoyed watching it as a show piece.
I'm waiting for Iplayer to watch the following dances as I got in from work after these guys had performed. (I did see Audley & Natalie but wasn't watching them as I was attending to my cats. They didn't understand that 'Strictly' was on and just wanted food!). I'll edit my post when I've watched them. (I've now edited the post and added my reviews below)
Jason & Kristina 7 (Paso Doble)
I liked their costumes. They certainly looked the part of the Paso Doble. I'm not sure what I didn't really like about it.. but it seemed a bit like a series of steps rather than a complete dance. Almost like Jason was counting in his head. There were moments where steps looked a bit skippy too. It could have been the music - much as I like Queen the music seemed a bit repetitive which could have made the steps seem like they were danced repetitvely. I can't quite put my finger on it. Jason is certainly very talented and performed with conviction and aggression - this just wasn't a performance that thrilled me. I'm sorry.
Alex & James 5 (Rumba)
Well if anyone could look gorgeous in a sheer catsuit it is Alex. She looked stunning but in my opinion also looked quite self-concious. She hit all her lines but I was just willing for her to really push down into the floor and use her hips. The costume was very brave but I think perhaps something with a little bit more material may have given her the confidence to use those hips. She also seemed to be struggling to move in the high heels. It was like she was dancing on top of the floor instead of using the floor to aid her. It is a tough dance and she did look good but it was more a case of 'picture' moments rather than dancing. If it hadn't been a rumba, I would have marked higher. I loved the 'Bolero' beginning.
Audley & Natalie 5 (Foxtrot)
What a beautiful dress Natalie wore! This looked lovely.. but Audley's dancing of the foxtrot was only a 5 to me. I did enjoy the performance and he looked very comfortable but I wanted him to step out some more and really feel the dance through his feet and legs. His posture was very good and his smile was adorable.
Looking forward to next week's Halloween special! Last year's one was so good so I hope this one lives up to expectations! I do like the idea of themes. I think it keeps Strictly fresh though I do hope they don't go away from the actual dances too much.
Couples who I think are in danger this week:-
Audley & Natalie, Rory & Erin, Nancy & Anton.
Couple who I think should leave: still Nancy & Anton
Couple who surprised me the most this week: Chelsee and Pasha - didn't think she coudl produce a quickstep like that. Was really surprised and thrilled.
My opinon on the rift between the judges and professional dancers that seems to be arising:- It's a tricky one. I can see why the professionals are frustrated by the seemingly constant references to their choreography (and I know I do it as well) but it does contribute to the celebrity's performance. Their ability to choreograph for their particular celebrity really does come into play. I suppose it's a bit like song choice on 'singing' shows. The choice of song REALLY does make a difference as does the choice of choreography on Strictly. I understand why it is hard for the judges not to comment on the choreography when it makes such a difference to the performance and I also understand why the professionals are upset that their choreography is being criticised when it seems that the focus should be on the 'dancing' ability of the celebrity. I don't think there's anything wrong with talking about the choreography but perhaps the judges could focus more on the celebritiy's dance ability before taking the choreography into account.. perhaps more a 70/30% situation? I think the pro's objections are more to when 'just' the choreography is being discussed and not the performance of the celebrity or when the choreography is deemed to be the downside to a performance. Professional dancers/teachers follow a code of professional etiquette whereby we don't criticise other professional's work and support our fellow professionals. I think perhaps some of the pros on Strictly feel that this practise is not being followed. It's a tricky situation.
Sunday, 16 October 2011
Bye to Dan & Katya
Well Dan was my choice to watch for potential but I don't find it a surprise that he left tonight. It's that 3rd from bottom syndrome! His Viennese Waltz was very stop-starty and he never really seemed to find his rhythm. The standard as a whole was pretty great for week 2 so it is a tough bunch of celebrities to be up against.
Nancy & Anton would have been my choice to leave and surely they'll make an exit within the next few weeks unless Nancy shows a dramatic improvement and other people drop in standard.
Professional Performance - West Side Story
Lots of energy and great aspects of the original film choreography. Great Broadway theme week! Bring on next Saturday!
Random note: Claudia's eyeliner really was a BIT too far out, I couldnt' stop looking at it. That was probably the intention?
Random thought: Alex reminds me of Natasha Kaplinsky (perhaps this will be James' year?)
Nancy & Anton would have been my choice to leave and surely they'll make an exit within the next few weeks unless Nancy shows a dramatic improvement and other people drop in standard.
Professional Performance - West Side Story
Lots of energy and great aspects of the original film choreography. Great Broadway theme week! Bring on next Saturday!
Random note: Claudia's eyeliner really was a BIT too far out, I couldnt' stop looking at it. That was probably the intention?
Random thought: Alex reminds me of Natasha Kaplinsky (perhaps this will be James' year?)
Saturday, 15 October 2011
Week 3 Scores - Broadway Week!
What a fabulous opening with "One" from one of my favourie musicals 'A Chorus Line'! It was a lovely touch to have all of the celebrities come on at the end of the number.
And how lovely to hear "Sir Bruce Forsyth" announced! Well deserved Sir Bruce!
Now here are my scores and opinions.
Holly & Artem - 7 (Tango - Cell Block Tango from 'Chicago')
I was curious to see this dance as I heard Holly say on It Takes Two that she hated musicals. Their routine was from 'Chicago' one of my other favourite musicals.. this seemed to be inspired from the film version. Holly's wig made her look very much like Catherine Zeta Jones who played the part of Velma in the film (On a side note... my two cats are called Roxie & Velma). Now onto the dance... as a whole piece, Holly played the part well and the dance routine was effective. As a tango.. there was barely any content and what steps I saw seemed to be done on the balls of the feet when going forward which made it look like she was trotting in stilettos and unable to manage the height of the shoes. It was certainly strong and passionate but I do feel there should have been more tango content. The music was perfect to do a tango to. I marked 7 but this could have been higher if the tango section had been done with a better technique. I do have to mention that she did deal very well when her dress got caught in her heel.
Dan & Katya - 6 (Viennese Waltz)
I had high hopes for Dan but this just seemed somewhat disjointed. The Viennese Waltz should be a flowing dance yet it didn't seem to really start. Lots of stopping.. and when it finally seemed like they were about to get a rhythm going they stopped again! He seemed rather flat footed but there wasn't much chance for him to get into the rhythm of the dance. His posture was quite nice and his leather waistcoat suited the music but I wish it had all had more flow. It seemed like he was delivering steps rather than actually 'dancing'. I do still believe he has the potential to do much better than this.
On a sidenote.. I write my reviews before listening to what the judges say on 'Strictly'. (Felt I had to say this as the judges seem to be agreeing with me some of the time).
Anita & Robin - 8 (Jive)
Anita has a great smile! Perfect for the jive and this had plenty of content and fit the 'Hairspray' theme. The speed was a good one. Often the jives are played super-fast and it is impossible for the celebrities to keep up but this slower speed meant that Anita got her steps in and was able to 'perform' the routine. I enjoyed this performance and though she matched Robin well.
Alex & James - 8 (Viennese Waltz 'Memory' from Cats)
Oh this was beautiful. A perfect routine for Alex from James. I loved the subtlety of the 'cats' paws at the start and end of the routine. In contrast to Dan & Katya's Viennese Waltz this flowed really well.. and even when they slowed down the momentum kept going. Of course it would have been easier for James to lead Alex than for Katya to lead Dan so Dan is at a disadvantage there. The dress was beautiful and I thought Alex did this the best she could have done at this stage in the competition. She definitely has further to go! My favourite performance so far.
Rory & Erin - 8 (Quickstep - Top Hat & Tails)
Oh I can't stop smiling. What a great show! I want to give Rory an 8 but I think it's more a 7. Umm.. changed my mind... given him an 8. Again, another great routine. Well done to Erin! It was just out of a Fred Astaire movie. I loved the opening and end and loved that it was also a great quickstep. Rory was very light on his feet and well in control of himself. I think his back could have been straighter but this is only the 3rd dance! He really got into character and delivered a very good quickstep.
Lulu & Brendan - 7 (Rumba - All I Ask Of You (Phantom))
Well I heard Brendan say on ITT that there wasn't much rumba content so I wasn't expecting much but there was a rumba 'look' to the routine. I'd have liked Lulu to have walked with straighter legs to emmulate the rumba style more but she made a good attempt. The song is beautiful and they both performed with emotion. The dry ice effect on the dance floor was very apt for the 'Phantom' setting but not too great for watching their feet. I thought Lulu's dress was perfect for their rendition of the routine. Brendan's cape was actually the same as the capes my girls performed in tonight at our show in their 'Phantom of the Opera' ballet medley. I liked the way he took the cape off and used it. A good performance but still hoping for more as Lulu's confidence grows.
Extra note after watching the judge's comments:- I did wonder if the 'lifts' rule applied to the 'Broadway' show as they did the lift and find it quite strange to see Len accepting the lift and Craig not!!!
Nancy & Anton - 5 (Tango)
Hmm.. what to make of this. Loved Anton's jacket. This was an ok performance. It was quite striking but there was something missing that I can't quite put my finger on. I was watching her feet and she seemed to be walking rather than dancing on the walks.. which I know sounds like a strange thing to say... but there are many ways to walk in a dance and I don't think she mastered the 'tango' walk. But this was certainly better than the previous two performances. It just didn't excite me.
Audley & Natalie - 5 (Quickstep - Too Darn Hot from 'Kiss Me Kate')
I love Audley's smile. I love his natural groove but the performance didn't work for me tonight. The dance also felt rather disjointed. The first section of 'quickstep' worked well. The second section went wrong which was sad as it was near the end of the routine. He has a good fluid rhythm but I don't think the dance was great tonight.
Sidenote: liked the lights/projection at the back at the start of the routine with 'starring Audley & Natalie'.
Robbie & Ola - 6 (Tango - Gimme Gimme Gimme (Mamma Mia))
The passion in this tango was fiery. I wanted Robbie to be the 'man after midnight'. Ola did a lot of the work in this routine though. She fiddled around him while he 'looked' the part but I dont' think that he competely was the part. Really enjoyed the performance though.
Russel & Flavia 7 (Foxtrot - Don't Rain on My Parade)
Their advantage.. one of the best songs of the night. Russell just loves this which makes me love it and makes me want him to go all the way! There was a lot of foxtrot in this routine which he managed well and smoothly. It was certainly more 'American movie' than elegant foxtrot but it had that showbiz finasse and he looked extrememly comfortable performing in that style. I wanted to be up there dancing too.
Jason and Krystina 8 (Tango - I Will Survive (Pricilla)
Well that was possibly the campest and most vocal tango I've ever seen on Strictly. The section where Jason & Krystina had their backs to the judges was Jason's finest musical 'camp' performance and then it was straight into a classic tango with what looked like shouts and rather masculine sounds! I feel Jason was using a lot of ball leads instead of heels but his posture for the tango sections was stunning and the routine was most enjoyable to watch. Can you tell I'm loving 'Broadway' week? (Love Jason's pink diamante collar)
Chelsee & Pasha 6 (Cha Cha)
I know she said she was going to tone it down.. but she was still dancing the cha cha as a 'disco' dance. The leotard costume did her no favours as it showed off her un-latin-like legs. A Latin dress may have helped disguise that somewhat. She definitely can dance but as of yet she hasn't adapted the style to the correct Latin dance. I actually suspect she will be better at the Ballroom dances as they're different to disco.
Harry & Aliona 7 (Jive - Greased Lightning)
As a show piece, this was a 9! Fabulous! Harry was a great 'Danny Zuko' but as a jive there was barely anything to judge. It's really hard to mark. I think if there had been more jive it would have been great and I could have warranted giving him a 9 but I think I've got to be stuck on 7 because there was barely a step of jive in there and it's so sad because the routine was a great show piece.
Best Performance of the Night
The one I want to watch again is Jason & Krystina's tango - but I'll will him to walk with heel leads.
Most Entrancing Performance of the Night
Alex & James' Viennese Waltz
Makes me want to get up and dance too
Russell & Flavia
Couple to leave
Nancy & Anton :(
Well there are my thoughts of the night.
Judge Peach
And how lovely to hear "Sir Bruce Forsyth" announced! Well deserved Sir Bruce!
Now here are my scores and opinions.
Holly & Artem - 7 (Tango - Cell Block Tango from 'Chicago')
I was curious to see this dance as I heard Holly say on It Takes Two that she hated musicals. Their routine was from 'Chicago' one of my other favourite musicals.. this seemed to be inspired from the film version. Holly's wig made her look very much like Catherine Zeta Jones who played the part of Velma in the film (On a side note... my two cats are called Roxie & Velma). Now onto the dance... as a whole piece, Holly played the part well and the dance routine was effective. As a tango.. there was barely any content and what steps I saw seemed to be done on the balls of the feet when going forward which made it look like she was trotting in stilettos and unable to manage the height of the shoes. It was certainly strong and passionate but I do feel there should have been more tango content. The music was perfect to do a tango to. I marked 7 but this could have been higher if the tango section had been done with a better technique. I do have to mention that she did deal very well when her dress got caught in her heel.
Dan & Katya - 6 (Viennese Waltz)
I had high hopes for Dan but this just seemed somewhat disjointed. The Viennese Waltz should be a flowing dance yet it didn't seem to really start. Lots of stopping.. and when it finally seemed like they were about to get a rhythm going they stopped again! He seemed rather flat footed but there wasn't much chance for him to get into the rhythm of the dance. His posture was quite nice and his leather waistcoat suited the music but I wish it had all had more flow. It seemed like he was delivering steps rather than actually 'dancing'. I do still believe he has the potential to do much better than this.
On a sidenote.. I write my reviews before listening to what the judges say on 'Strictly'. (Felt I had to say this as the judges seem to be agreeing with me some of the time).
Anita & Robin - 8 (Jive)
Anita has a great smile! Perfect for the jive and this had plenty of content and fit the 'Hairspray' theme. The speed was a good one. Often the jives are played super-fast and it is impossible for the celebrities to keep up but this slower speed meant that Anita got her steps in and was able to 'perform' the routine. I enjoyed this performance and though she matched Robin well.
Alex & James - 8 (Viennese Waltz 'Memory' from Cats)
Oh this was beautiful. A perfect routine for Alex from James. I loved the subtlety of the 'cats' paws at the start and end of the routine. In contrast to Dan & Katya's Viennese Waltz this flowed really well.. and even when they slowed down the momentum kept going. Of course it would have been easier for James to lead Alex than for Katya to lead Dan so Dan is at a disadvantage there. The dress was beautiful and I thought Alex did this the best she could have done at this stage in the competition. She definitely has further to go! My favourite performance so far.
Rory & Erin - 8 (Quickstep - Top Hat & Tails)
Oh I can't stop smiling. What a great show! I want to give Rory an 8 but I think it's more a 7. Umm.. changed my mind... given him an 8. Again, another great routine. Well done to Erin! It was just out of a Fred Astaire movie. I loved the opening and end and loved that it was also a great quickstep. Rory was very light on his feet and well in control of himself. I think his back could have been straighter but this is only the 3rd dance! He really got into character and delivered a very good quickstep.
Lulu & Brendan - 7 (Rumba - All I Ask Of You (Phantom))
Well I heard Brendan say on ITT that there wasn't much rumba content so I wasn't expecting much but there was a rumba 'look' to the routine. I'd have liked Lulu to have walked with straighter legs to emmulate the rumba style more but she made a good attempt. The song is beautiful and they both performed with emotion. The dry ice effect on the dance floor was very apt for the 'Phantom' setting but not too great for watching their feet. I thought Lulu's dress was perfect for their rendition of the routine. Brendan's cape was actually the same as the capes my girls performed in tonight at our show in their 'Phantom of the Opera' ballet medley. I liked the way he took the cape off and used it. A good performance but still hoping for more as Lulu's confidence grows.
Extra note after watching the judge's comments:- I did wonder if the 'lifts' rule applied to the 'Broadway' show as they did the lift and find it quite strange to see Len accepting the lift and Craig not!!!
Nancy & Anton - 5 (Tango)
Hmm.. what to make of this. Loved Anton's jacket. This was an ok performance. It was quite striking but there was something missing that I can't quite put my finger on. I was watching her feet and she seemed to be walking rather than dancing on the walks.. which I know sounds like a strange thing to say... but there are many ways to walk in a dance and I don't think she mastered the 'tango' walk. But this was certainly better than the previous two performances. It just didn't excite me.
Audley & Natalie - 5 (Quickstep - Too Darn Hot from 'Kiss Me Kate')
I love Audley's smile. I love his natural groove but the performance didn't work for me tonight. The dance also felt rather disjointed. The first section of 'quickstep' worked well. The second section went wrong which was sad as it was near the end of the routine. He has a good fluid rhythm but I don't think the dance was great tonight.
Sidenote: liked the lights/projection at the back at the start of the routine with 'starring Audley & Natalie'.
Robbie & Ola - 6 (Tango - Gimme Gimme Gimme (Mamma Mia))
The passion in this tango was fiery. I wanted Robbie to be the 'man after midnight'. Ola did a lot of the work in this routine though. She fiddled around him while he 'looked' the part but I dont' think that he competely was the part. Really enjoyed the performance though.
Russel & Flavia 7 (Foxtrot - Don't Rain on My Parade)
Their advantage.. one of the best songs of the night. Russell just loves this which makes me love it and makes me want him to go all the way! There was a lot of foxtrot in this routine which he managed well and smoothly. It was certainly more 'American movie' than elegant foxtrot but it had that showbiz finasse and he looked extrememly comfortable performing in that style. I wanted to be up there dancing too.
Jason and Krystina 8 (Tango - I Will Survive (Pricilla)
Well that was possibly the campest and most vocal tango I've ever seen on Strictly. The section where Jason & Krystina had their backs to the judges was Jason's finest musical 'camp' performance and then it was straight into a classic tango with what looked like shouts and rather masculine sounds! I feel Jason was using a lot of ball leads instead of heels but his posture for the tango sections was stunning and the routine was most enjoyable to watch. Can you tell I'm loving 'Broadway' week? (Love Jason's pink diamante collar)
Chelsee & Pasha 6 (Cha Cha)
I know she said she was going to tone it down.. but she was still dancing the cha cha as a 'disco' dance. The leotard costume did her no favours as it showed off her un-latin-like legs. A Latin dress may have helped disguise that somewhat. She definitely can dance but as of yet she hasn't adapted the style to the correct Latin dance. I actually suspect she will be better at the Ballroom dances as they're different to disco.
Harry & Aliona 7 (Jive - Greased Lightning)
As a show piece, this was a 9! Fabulous! Harry was a great 'Danny Zuko' but as a jive there was barely anything to judge. It's really hard to mark. I think if there had been more jive it would have been great and I could have warranted giving him a 9 but I think I've got to be stuck on 7 because there was barely a step of jive in there and it's so sad because the routine was a great show piece.
Best Performance of the Night
The one I want to watch again is Jason & Krystina's tango - but I'll will him to walk with heel leads.
Most Entrancing Performance of the Night
Alex & James' Viennese Waltz
Makes me want to get up and dance too
Russell & Flavia
Couple to leave
Nancy & Anton :(
Well there are my thoughts of the night.
Judge Peach
Monday, 10 October 2011
Goodbye Edwina & Vincent
A tear was shed... no more dancing for Edwina :(
It's always heartbreaking for the professional to be the first to leave.. but gutting for a celebrity to leave who was enjoying it and wanting to learn more dancing.
I do think Anton actually looked disappointed that he wasn't the one to leave. If that is the case I don't blame him as Nancy is not coming across very well on camera.
I was glad that Audley remained as he definitely didn't deserve to be in the bottom two.. and relieved Brendan & Lulu got through.
It's always heartbreaking for the professional to be the first to leave.. but gutting for a celebrity to leave who was enjoying it and wanting to learn more dancing.
I do think Anton actually looked disappointed that he wasn't the one to leave. If that is the case I don't blame him as Nancy is not coming across very well on camera.
I was glad that Audley remained as he definitely didn't deserve to be in the bottom two.. and relieved Brendan & Lulu got through.
Week 2 Scores
Chelsee & Pascha (will check how his name is slept later) - Salsa. My score - 7
For me it had lots of energy but was more like a "Disco" dance than a Salsa. Chelsee has so much potential and it really seems to me that she has a 'disco' dancing past so she needs to learn how to ground her feet more and use the floor instead of bouncing on top of it. She is one to watch! (Loved the armography section)
Edwina & Vincent - Foxtrot (Or rather American Smooth). My score - 4.
Very disappointing. I don't like to criticise the professionals but this was more an American Smooth. I guess it was an attempt to hide Edwina's dance ability in the foxtrot and to appeal to the voting public by adding props and making the routine more interesting and I guess I can understand Vincent's reasons for doing so as the actual foxtrot section wasn't very good.
Audley & Natalie - Salsa My score - 6.
This actually had a fair amount of rhythm. Personality was great! I think Audley has potential to really move his hips. He managed some quick step movements and arm movements but was let down by his flat feet and at times his lack of energy.. he did some very bad looking drag runs towards the stage as he headed there for the final section.. but it was a joy to watch. (And a great track of music!)
Alex & James - Foxtrot. My score - 7
I enjoyed this. Alex looked most stunning at the start and end of the routine. During the foxtrot she needed to lower her shoulders to correct the posture. She seemed to be coming away from the floor with her feet so attention for me was drawn to some clumpy steps.. but she stepped out really well with James and really made a good attempt at the foxtrot. Beautiful smile and gorgeous feather fan. Shows promise! (Loved the jewelled neck piece)
Dan & Katya - Salsa. My score - 7
I could REALLY like Dan I think. Loved the VT of the tennis. The Salsa itself for me seemed a bit bitty. I liked the bits of salsa but they weren't linked together.. they seemed to be interrupted with lifts and poses. I would have liked more continuity so that I could have seen Dan's rhythm some more.
Brendan & Lulu - Foxtrot. My score - 6
Brendan could not have looked more swish. The song lyrics "falling to pieces".. were what I was scared of Lulu doing through the routine. It did seem like Brendan was carrying her around the floor and she seemed scared to lift her head up (I'm not surprised after forgetting her routine last week). It was still a pretty tough foxtrot routine and I do think Brendan needs to simplify the choreography to help her along for the first few weeks. The mirror was interesting but not sure it really added too much to the routine. Hope Lulu gets some confidence back and can really start to learn to dance. I would love her to do well as she is such a fabulous performer. I think the Latin dances are going to suit her more if she can nail the choreography. (In shock slightly after Brendan's forward roll to Tess!)
Holly & Artem Salsa My score - 8
Very smooth and relaxed. Enjoyable to watch (even though i didn't care for the music)
Rory & Erin Salsa. My score - 7
Loved the music and the continuous salsa style. Great shimmys! Rory seemed a little flat-footed at times but really nailed the routine. Looking forward to seeing more of Rory's dancing! I was close to giving an 8.
Robbie & Ola Foxtrot My score - 8
Wow! What a surprise! This was great! Lovely stepping out of feet. Good posture. Excellent flow of movement. Loved the solo at the beginning with an elegant quick-moving zig-zag from Robbie. I was so impressed! I'd like to watch it again. Best dance of the night so far. Almost feel like giving a 9.
Anita & Robin Salsa. My score - 5.
I'm not loving the dress. Brave outrageous outfit but I don't think it worked for Anita for this dance. It showed off too much of her legs which looked gangly throughout this dance. Very little hip action though good content in the routine. She smiled throughout and tried to give but I think nerves overcame her.
Jason & Krystina Foxtrot My score - 8
Jason has such a fabulous personality and is a great actor so it was no surprise that this foxtrot looked straight out of the movie. The actual foxtrot section was almost correct. He was trying with the correct footwork and trying with the posture but he did look stiff as he held his head up. I'm sure he'll learn to relax more in future weeks.
Nancy & Anton Salsa. My score - 4
Oh dear. This lady actually did try to perform with some style and the start was particularly effective.. but her feet got carried away during the routine and it didn't seem to be the correct steps. Nancy seems to have potential but this was a messy performance unfortunately.
Harry & Aliona Foxtrot My score - 8
Lovely and smooth. Harry needs to lift his head a little more to create a better frame but he stepped out really well and it was a good rendition of the foxtrot.
Russel & Flavia Salsa My score - 6
This is a difficult one. I enjoyed it but also felt a bit awkward. I didn't like the beginning. I'd rather Russell had stayed serious. He can move so he doesn't need to create comedy scenarios. The music was a bit off-putting as it sounded more like a samba than a salsa hence the inclusion of samba steps into the routine. There was a lot of good salsa in the routine but due to the speed of the music the steps weren't always finished off and it seemed like they had to allow several bars of the music just to catch up with the feet. Russell needs to work on pointing his toes when his leg is up in the air too. I think I was slightly disappiinted. I originally gave a 7 but have changed to a 6.
My favourite routine suprisingly was Robbie & Ola's! It's the one I'd like to see again. I hate to say it but I think my choice for leaving would be Nancy. I'd be happy for them all to stay until the final :) Nobody should leave!
Judge Peach
For me it had lots of energy but was more like a "Disco" dance than a Salsa. Chelsee has so much potential and it really seems to me that she has a 'disco' dancing past so she needs to learn how to ground her feet more and use the floor instead of bouncing on top of it. She is one to watch! (Loved the armography section)
Edwina & Vincent - Foxtrot (Or rather American Smooth). My score - 4.
Very disappointing. I don't like to criticise the professionals but this was more an American Smooth. I guess it was an attempt to hide Edwina's dance ability in the foxtrot and to appeal to the voting public by adding props and making the routine more interesting and I guess I can understand Vincent's reasons for doing so as the actual foxtrot section wasn't very good.
Audley & Natalie - Salsa My score - 6.
This actually had a fair amount of rhythm. Personality was great! I think Audley has potential to really move his hips. He managed some quick step movements and arm movements but was let down by his flat feet and at times his lack of energy.. he did some very bad looking drag runs towards the stage as he headed there for the final section.. but it was a joy to watch. (And a great track of music!)
Alex & James - Foxtrot. My score - 7
I enjoyed this. Alex looked most stunning at the start and end of the routine. During the foxtrot she needed to lower her shoulders to correct the posture. She seemed to be coming away from the floor with her feet so attention for me was drawn to some clumpy steps.. but she stepped out really well with James and really made a good attempt at the foxtrot. Beautiful smile and gorgeous feather fan. Shows promise! (Loved the jewelled neck piece)
Dan & Katya - Salsa. My score - 7
I could REALLY like Dan I think. Loved the VT of the tennis. The Salsa itself for me seemed a bit bitty. I liked the bits of salsa but they weren't linked together.. they seemed to be interrupted with lifts and poses. I would have liked more continuity so that I could have seen Dan's rhythm some more.
Brendan & Lulu - Foxtrot. My score - 6
Brendan could not have looked more swish. The song lyrics "falling to pieces".. were what I was scared of Lulu doing through the routine. It did seem like Brendan was carrying her around the floor and she seemed scared to lift her head up (I'm not surprised after forgetting her routine last week). It was still a pretty tough foxtrot routine and I do think Brendan needs to simplify the choreography to help her along for the first few weeks. The mirror was interesting but not sure it really added too much to the routine. Hope Lulu gets some confidence back and can really start to learn to dance. I would love her to do well as she is such a fabulous performer. I think the Latin dances are going to suit her more if she can nail the choreography. (In shock slightly after Brendan's forward roll to Tess!)
Holly & Artem Salsa My score - 8
Very smooth and relaxed. Enjoyable to watch (even though i didn't care for the music)
Rory & Erin Salsa. My score - 7
Loved the music and the continuous salsa style. Great shimmys! Rory seemed a little flat-footed at times but really nailed the routine. Looking forward to seeing more of Rory's dancing! I was close to giving an 8.
Robbie & Ola Foxtrot My score - 8
Wow! What a surprise! This was great! Lovely stepping out of feet. Good posture. Excellent flow of movement. Loved the solo at the beginning with an elegant quick-moving zig-zag from Robbie. I was so impressed! I'd like to watch it again. Best dance of the night so far. Almost feel like giving a 9.
Anita & Robin Salsa. My score - 5.
I'm not loving the dress. Brave outrageous outfit but I don't think it worked for Anita for this dance. It showed off too much of her legs which looked gangly throughout this dance. Very little hip action though good content in the routine. She smiled throughout and tried to give but I think nerves overcame her.
Jason & Krystina Foxtrot My score - 8
Jason has such a fabulous personality and is a great actor so it was no surprise that this foxtrot looked straight out of the movie. The actual foxtrot section was almost correct. He was trying with the correct footwork and trying with the posture but he did look stiff as he held his head up. I'm sure he'll learn to relax more in future weeks.
Nancy & Anton Salsa. My score - 4
Oh dear. This lady actually did try to perform with some style and the start was particularly effective.. but her feet got carried away during the routine and it didn't seem to be the correct steps. Nancy seems to have potential but this was a messy performance unfortunately.
Harry & Aliona Foxtrot My score - 8
Lovely and smooth. Harry needs to lift his head a little more to create a better frame but he stepped out really well and it was a good rendition of the foxtrot.
Russel & Flavia Salsa My score - 6
This is a difficult one. I enjoyed it but also felt a bit awkward. I didn't like the beginning. I'd rather Russell had stayed serious. He can move so he doesn't need to create comedy scenarios. The music was a bit off-putting as it sounded more like a samba than a salsa hence the inclusion of samba steps into the routine. There was a lot of good salsa in the routine but due to the speed of the music the steps weren't always finished off and it seemed like they had to allow several bars of the music just to catch up with the feet. Russell needs to work on pointing his toes when his leg is up in the air too. I think I was slightly disappiinted. I originally gave a 7 but have changed to a 6.
My favourite routine suprisingly was Robbie & Ola's! It's the one I'd like to see again. I hate to say it but I think my choice for leaving would be Nancy. I'd be happy for them all to stay until the final :) Nobody should leave!
Judge Peach
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)